Re: FM's FIFA Ratings

by **Cathalio11** Mon 24 Oct 2011, 19:31

Just thought I'd copy the original poste and paste it, and edit to give mine for the fun.

jonnyynnoj - 87
Chef - 80
Deerhaunter - 82
Maddude - 24
Socrates - 78
ace000 - 77
Lloyd Banks - 74
CircleBoy - 73
Ghost - 75
Donny - 75
mc smiley - 75
GOKU - 75
F1 - 73
V-11 - 76
thor - 70
Rachel - 75
Aero - dunno
any1 - 69
Zizou - 72
Alec Baldwin - 74
Cookies - 78
Blazing - 70
Aidan - 70
rising star - 68
DEVINURDOG - 70
TTom - 76
NavJuve - pulled a nazzy
opc - 70
Shockboy - dunno
Tanzim - dunno
Mick - 67
play4fun - 63
Griffin - 64
W - 75
Joey - 60
QEZO - 46

Tried to pull people closer together as I thought it was more fair. So more dis-improved the 80s and improved the lowers, especially the good ones.
Just did it for fun, don't fucking slay me.
Plus, it's just my opinion so I'm obviously not right on a few, just based on how I see it recently.

by **CircleBoy** Mon 24 Oct 2011, 19:32

Yes but its not like he's a passenger blazing, he plays for the team for at least a half every game (barring connection issues). Also way to ignore him holding ARRIBA to 0-0.

by **opc** Mon 24 Oct 2011, 19:53

I put Cath's changes in order, just so I can go all decision maths on this shit. I put Cath in where I think he should go too.

jonnyynnoj - 87
Deerhaunter - 82
Chef - 80
Socrates - 78
Cookies - 78
ace000 - 77
TTom - 76
V-11 - 76
W - 75
Ghost - 75
Donny - 75
mc smiley - 75
GOKU - 75
Rachel - 75
Alec Baldwin - 74
Lloyd Banks - 74
F1 - 73
CircleBoy - 73
Zizou - 72
Blazing - 70
Aidan - 70
opc - 70
thor - 70
DEVINURDOG - 70
any1 - 69
rising star - 68
Mick - 67
Griffin - 64
play4fun - 63
Joey - 60
QEZO - 46
NavJuve - pulled a nazzy
Shockboy - dunno
Tanzim - dunno
Aero - dunno
Maddude - 24
Cathfag - -∞

by **Cathalio11** Mon 24 Oct 2011, 19:55

Watch it!

by **opc** Mon 24 Oct 2011, 19:59

Cathalio11 wrote:Watch it!

Oh, sorry, too high.

by J.Mata Mon 24 Oct 2011, 20:10

may i have a rating too? Very Happy

by **Lekumberri** Wed 26 Oct 2011, 00:06

jmata wrote:may i have a rating too?

The same!!

I think 73 could be a good rating.

by Alec Baldwin Wed 26 Oct 2011, 19:26

Someone should do Football Manager ratings for everyone...

by Gonzalo Wed 26 Oct 2011, 19:43

im probably 79 rate

by Blazing Wed 26 Oct 2011, 21:30

play4fun wrote:im probably 79 rate

No. Gtfo.

by Naznek Wed 26 Oct 2011, 22:07

Me 68?

by Locke Wed 09 Nov 2011, 23:40

Rate me!

by Vargo Thu 10 Nov 2011, 07:30

I think we're overrating ourselves. I would rather remove 10 points from everyone, leaving room for improving.
Besides, anyone here having 90 or more is way overkill if 99 is perfection. I see alot of good players here, but not that good.

A player with about 90 rating imo, should have very high offensive and defensive awareness to start with (based on role) to be able to read the play, then the creativity and tactical mind to act on it, plus the skills to make it happen. That includes teamwork, positioning, pass/cross, touch, long shots, dribbling, blocking etc..

I'd rate the best player around here for about 82 just to give you guys some perspective on my view.

by **opc** Thu 10 Nov 2011, 17:34

Vargo wrote:I think we're overrating ourselves. I would rather remove 10 points from everyone, leaving room for improving.
Besides, anyone here having 90 or more is way overkill if 99 is perfection. I see alot of good players here, but not that good.

A player with about 90 rating imo, should have very high offensive and defensive awareness to start with (based on role) to be able to read the play, then the creativity and tactical mind to act on it, plus the skills to make it happen. That includes teamwork, positioning, pass/cross, touch, long shots, dribbling, blocking etc..

I'd rate the best player around here for about 82 just to give you guys some perspective on my view.

I completely agree with this. I think the worst players are underrated too, bar one or two players.

by Blazing Thu 10 Nov 2011, 18:54

Vargo wrote:I think we're overrating ourselves. I would rather remove 10 points from everyone, leaving room for improving.
Besides, anyone here having 90 or more is way overkill if 99 is perfection. I see alot of good players here, but not that good.

A player with about 90 rating imo, should have very high offensive and defensive awareness to start with (based on role) to be able to read the play, then the creativity and tactical mind to act on it, plus the skills to make it happen. That includes teamwork, positioning, pass/cross, touch, long shots, dribbling, blocking etc..

I'd rate the best player around here for about 82 just to give you guys some perspective on my view.

No one can cross here.

by Guest Thu 10 Nov 2011, 20:27

Best player gets given 85. Says take 10 off everyone, then says the best here is 82, only 3 off what was put.

Blazing you're a mong too. people can cross, it's just you that can't.

by Vargo Thu 10 Nov 2011, 21:48

Donny wrote:Best player gets given 85. Says take 10 off everyone, then says the best here is 82, only 3 off what was put.

I suppose I was exaggerating too when I said 82, probably because I read some posts about how some should be rated 90+. Though I still stand by what I said about lowering the score. Don't get me wrong though, 75 is still a whole lot better than the average player imo and it would give lots of room for potential improvement. Other than that it looks to me like balanced ratings.

To further discuss my point:

Donny wrote:Don't think of this as being one of the worst players, everyone in that list is a decent player tbh. No one ball chase or misses open goals over and over again. You'd be 20's if you did that.

The 20-29 bracket seems quite high for someone who would play like that imo, which is why I would rather lower the score for everyone instead of wasting 10 good points that could better describe highly skilled players (which we have an interest in rating) but are now reserved for people that would genuinely forget which team they're playing for.

by any1 Fri 11 Nov 2011, 11:28

Nice idea to rate us all!

btw, wonder how many of you think I'm on 69?

by **Cam_Sampbell** Sun 20 Nov 2011, 23:48

One for me? I'm rather curious!

by **Cathalio11** Mon 21 Nov 2011, 02:44

the more you play with us, the better idea We have of how good you are. Ive only seen you for a few games but would estimate you at around 75/76

by Mick Mon 21 Nov 2011, 09:49

Can we redo these all? I'm not that low

by Adarax Mon 21 Nov 2011, 12:04

Agree, Mick's been improving Wink

Anyone wanna get me on the list?

by Starfox Tue 22 Nov 2011, 22:50

Any ratings for Starfox? Be kind Razz

by Guest Tue 22 Nov 2011, 23:17

Someone else can if they want. I'm not making people cry again.

by Blazing Tue 22 Nov 2011, 23:47

I could if people wanted.

by **opc** Wed 23 Nov 2011, 00:05

Blazing wrote:I could if people wanted.

inb4 me at -1

by **Cathalio11** Wed 23 Nov 2011, 00:50

Ill organise it to be re done in the next few days, seeing as people are interested by randomly rejecting some of the original members of the site.

Ollie and myself cant be ranked individually though. Must be opcath

by **opc** Wed 23 Nov 2011, 01:37

Cathalio11 wrote:Ill organise it to be re done in the next few days, seeing as people are interested by randomly rejecting some of the original members of the site.

Ollie and myself cant be ranked individually though. Must be opcath

THIS

by Vargo Wed 23 Nov 2011, 07:34

or maybe we should just stick to official game ratings

by **-rising.star-** Wed 28 Dec 2011, 14:26

Should update this Very Happy

by **Ghost** Wed 28 Dec 2011, 14:33

Yeah, OPC has been a beast lately.

by Guest Wed 28 Dec 2011, 16:13

Right, I'll kind of do this. I need four volunteers to rate the players, I'll post on here a list of all the players then the four people PM me their ratings back and I'll do one too aswell as average the five ratings for a fair reflection. Post in here if you fancy rating them.

Maddude
Mick
Deerhaunter
Ghost

Done.

by Alec Baldwin Wed 28 Dec 2011, 16:14

Donny wrote:Right, I'll kind of do this. I need four volunteers to rate the players, I'll post on here a list of all the players then the four people PM me their ratings back and I'll do one too aswell as average the five ratings for a fair reflection. Post in here if you fancy rating them.

I can offer some ratings, but not a lot...

by **deerhaunter99** Wed 28 Dec 2011, 16:19

I'll chip in with a few ratings that I feel should be adjusted or whatever!

by Mick Wed 28 Dec 2011, 16:22

I can rate since im pretty much always on Very Happy

( this is my life)

by **opc** Wed 28 Dec 2011, 16:43

Ghost wrote:Yeah, OPC has been a beast lately.

This guy... this guy knows.

by Locke Thu 29 Dec 2011, 07:04

I can rate as well, If you PM me names Ill get back with my honest opinion

by any1 Thu 29 Dec 2011, 23:11

Problem with this is that I'm always gonna end up low 'cause of no league participation. Very Happy

Problem? Advantage, I mean!

by Guest Fri 30 Dec 2011, 22:32

Right, heres the list of players.

Aero
Edgar Davids
Ghost
Ttom
Usopp
3V3RAUX
Cam Sampbell
crib$
Mick
NJ
deerhaunter99
F1
jonnyynnoj
Sukh
Griffin
Locke
OvoXo
Rachel
Tanzim
Cheese
GOKU
QEZO
rising.st4r
Zizou
Attaxsh0t
Cathalio11
Maddude
opc
Cr3aToR
DDS
DEVINURDOG
Fergy
Vargo
Aaron
Aidan
kambu
Klinsa
Adarax
Blazing
Chef
Ghenge|Plik
Cookies
Fabregas
J.Mata
Lekumberri
mc smiley
/<r!$
Shiznit
Shockboy
thor91
Donny
Gary
Kaka
Lloyd Banks
socrates

The 4 people who are doing the ratings should rate as many as they possibly can then PM the results to me. Once I've had all four back I'll then post the average up of all the ratings. You also can't rate yourself.

by Adarax Sat 31 Dec 2011, 01:08

Why not just put everyone in order from the best to worst judged on overall skill level? Easier than trying to put the skill in a form of a number.

by **Lloyd Banks** Sat 31 Dec 2011, 14:01

because you can't compare a keeper to a striker, need individual ratings

by Guest Sat 31 Dec 2011, 15:14

Individual ratings for everyone from a team of 6 highly trained judges were acquired, these were then averaged and these are the official season 2 ratings.

1st jonnyynnoj - 86
2nd deerhaunter99 - 83
3rd Chef - 81
4th kambu - 81
5th Cathalio11 - 81
6th socrates - 80
7th Maddude - 79
8th Attaxsh0t - 79
9th Lloyd Banks - 78
10th Gary - 78
11th rising.st4r - 77
12th Kaka - 77
13th Cheese - 76
14th mc smiley - 75
15th Donny - 75
16th Cookies - 75
17th Aidan - 75
18th Klinsa - 75
19th NJ - 75
20th Aaron - 74
21st crib$ - 74
22nd DEVINURDOG - 74
23rd Fabregas - 74
24th Ttom - 74
25th GOKU - 74
26th Vargo - 74
27th F1 - 74
28th J.Mata - 74
29th Sukh - 74
30th Lekumberri - 73
31st opc - 73
32nd Zizou - 72
33rd Rachel - 72
34th Ghost - 72
35th Adarax - 72
36th Aero - 72
37th Usopp - 72
38th Tanzim - 71
39th Edgar Davids - 70
40th Shockboy - 70
41st Mick - 69
42nd OvoXo - 69
43rd Blazing - 69
44th DDS - 68
45th Cam Sampbell - 68
46th Ghenge|Plik - 68
47th Cr3aToR - 68
48th Shiznit - 68
49th /<r!$ - 68
50th thor91 - 68
51st Griffin - 67
52nd Locke - 67
53rd 3V3RAUX - 66
54th Fergy - 62
55th QEZO - 54

by **deerhaunter99** Sat 31 Dec 2011, 15:17

Let's not have arguments over this!! Can we rather look at it and think what can we improve? To give ourself a better rating.. If you wish I'm sure we can list everything we believe you can improve on..etc.etc. Have fun

by **-rising.star-** Sat 31 Dec 2011, 15:29

^ Above ratings,F1,I think is way too low down on that.

by **aeRo** Sat 31 Dec 2011, 15:35

I think I've gotten worse since the last one, you guys are too nice! haha

by Mick Sat 31 Dec 2011, 15:38

Thought I would be rated a little higher than just a few but meh

by Guest Sat 31 Dec 2011, 15:52

Mick wrote:Thought I would be rated a little higher than just a few but meh

Mick & Blazing easily under-rated.

by Guest Sat 31 Dec 2011, 15:55

League Team Overall
Division 1 Arriba - 78.90
Division 1 Cathletico - 77.93
Division 1 Soccerettes - 77.64
Division 2 Deadly Monkeys - 76.33
Division 1 NWA - 74.37
Division 2 MasterChefs - 72.42
Division 2 AC Dead People - 71.86
Division 1 Bombay Badboys - 70.70
Division 2 Action Men - 70.44
Division 1 Circle's Boy's - 69.23
Division 2 Bayern Neverlosin - 69.10
Division 2 ShockTactix - 68.17

by DDS Sat 31 Dec 2011, 16:11

44th ain't bad i supposed to say I haven't actually played a game yet :f

by **Usopp** Sat 31 Dec 2011, 16:35

37th - 72

by Sponsored content