Mafia - Day 8

Lynch votes:
Cheese (Deer, Socrates, Hesur, Edgar, Ghost, Adarax, Banks)
Fergy (Cheese)
Ghost (Griffin)

Warnings:
Cheese - 1
Fergy - 1
TTom - 1

Cheese was lynched. He was:

Spoiler:

Night 5 has begun and will last until Wednesday 20:00.

No nighttalking.

Two people died during the night. One was Griffin who was:

Spoiler:

The other was Fergy who was:

Spoiler:

Day 6 has now begun and will last until Friday 20:00.

Lynch: TTom
Last lurker alive?

But it's quite annoying to play without knowing the number of baddies or even the actual different roles.
But from the 2 deaths it's safe to assume there is at least 1 Mafia remaining (doubt any more than 3 total would be fair) and a serial killer or other obscure baddie/neutral role alive.

6 townies/obscure pro-town roles vs 2 baddies? Can we guess them? If one of them doesn't hang by the end of the day, town has lost.

Lynch: TTom.

I was actually going to vote for Fergy this round, too. Thanks, serial killer!

How are you so sure it's a serial killer? It could easily be a vigilante, which would make more sense as they didn't use their role the first few nights. Unless of course, you are the serial killer.

Edgar Davids wrote:How are you so sure it's a serial killer? It could easily be a vigilante, which would make more sense as they didn't use their role the first few nights. Unless of course, you are the serial killer.

I don't think it's a vigilante. Whoever it is has already killed a townie as well as a mafia, and a vigilante probably wouldn't be so reckless with their choices as a serial killer would be.

That said, with some of the stuff that's already happened in this game it wouldn't surprise me.

Yes but if it was a serial killer, why would they not kill anyone the first few nights?

Maybe jonny fucked up the role a bit, like "You need to spend the first night to find a fucking gun first lol".

LYNCH GHOST
Ttom pointed out to me some of ghosts suspicious behaviour and i agree with him. Such as ghost saying he doesnt think its fergy - then after fergy is found out to be mafia he says "i was going to vote fergy next round".
Not sure if this is ttom trying to stop himself being lynched but if we lynch ghost and he is a townie then we will know for sure if ttom is mafia

Indeed.

Game's over for townies now, anyway. I don't mind being sacrificed.

If I was mafia why was I voting for Fergy and trying to get other people to do the same to save Mick? On the other hand Ghost was drawing attention away from Fergy and onto Mick/Aidan who were both townies, infact anyone he 'suspects' always seems to end up being a townie.

The game isn't over for townies either at all, anyone can see that, it's a pretty obvious (and poor) bluff.

Lynch - Ghost

Since there's been a lack of votes and it's a Friday night, I'm going to extend this until 8pm tomorrow.

Hmmm, it's difficult but I think TTom has been more suspicious than Ghost. Don't like the idea of letting the likes of Hesur slip by though as he's hardly posted at all.

Lynch: TTom

Lynch Ghost - TTom makes a good point about Ghost drawing attention away from fergy, pretty suspicious

changing vote to GHOAST

Dat bandwagon.

All I can say is what cheese said. Vote me and you are killing another townie.

Changing vote back to TTom

Changing mine to Deer. His voting pattern in the first few days is suspect. And he agreed with me when I didn't think it was Fergy. Seemed reluctant to lynch Mad when it was all but confirmed he was Mafia, too.

LYNCH - DEER.

Lynch Ghost - not because he's voted for me, but cause Ttom did have valid reasons. I'm not voting Hesur because I *think* he's a townie. Although he's very quiet so I'm suspicious.

Lynch DEER. Ghost raises some good points.

Lynch Votes:
Ghost (Socrates, TTom, Banks, Deer)
TTom (Adarax, Edgar, Adarax)
Deer (Ghost, Hesur)

Ghost was lynched. He was:

Spoiler:

Night 6 has now begun and will last until Sunday 20:00 (trying to speed it up now there's not many night actions left).

No nighttalking.

One person died during the night: TTom. He was:

Spoiler:

Day 7 has now begun and will last until Monday 20:00 (again, trying to speed things up).

Nice discussion guys

Day extended till tomorrow 8pm as the townies had an extended sleep.

lol oops.

Okay my vote is on Hesur. He's hardly contributed to the game throughout and has just lurked and let the townies kill each other. He's definitely the most suspicious out of everyone left.

I'm gonna vote Deer again, mainly for the reasons Ghost brought up, and I think he is a suspicious character.

I've had a thorough look through the posts and I believe Soc to be Mafia:

LYNCH - SOC

Lynch soc
Hunch

every time i seem to follow the votes of other people, it ends in a townie being killed.

vote - adarax. he seemed suspicious from the start, over explaining himself and what not

Lynch deer
I was convinced ghost was gonna be mafia so im gonna vote for who who he voted for as i believe he had valid reasons.

Lynch votes:
Deer (Hesur, Soc)
Soc (Deer, Adarax)
Adarax (Banks)
Hesur (Edgar)

No one was lynched. Night 7 has now begun and will last until Wednesday 20:00.

Two people died in the night. One was deer who was:

Spoiler:

The other was Adarax, found decapitated. He was:

Spoiler:

Day 8 has now begun and will last until Thursday 20:00.

We dont seem to be getting this right at all so im gonna go for who i think is the most suspicious person left.
LYNCH HESUR

Lynch Edgar.

He seems to question a lot of the decisions, and this activity makes me think he is a member of the Mafia.

What!? Do you not understand that the concept of the game is not to blindly lynch but to question other people and deduce who is mafia? Ridiculous reasoning and just backs up my decision to go for you. This should have been done yesterday but no one else followed me with it.

Lynch: Hesur

Edgar Davids wrote:What!? Do you not understand that the concept of the game is not to blindly lynch but to question other people and deduce who is mafia? Ridiculous reasoning and just backs up my decision to go for you. This should have been done yesterday but no one else followed me with it.

Lynch: Hesur

I have never played before

But I believe you are the most likely to be a member of the Mafia of the ones who are left.

Hesur wrote:Lynch Edgar.

He seems to question a lot of the decisions, and this activity makes me think he is a member of the Mafia.

We have got most of the decisions wrong though, if edgar was mafia he would go along with them surely?

socrates wrote:

Hesur wrote:Lynch Edgar.

He seems to question a lot of the decisions, and this activity makes me think he is a member of the Mafia.

We have got most of the decisions wrong though, if edgar was mafia he would go along with them surely?

He has played before and is prehaps doing this to make you think that.

Lynch - hesur. sorry hesur it's nothing personal, i just don't know what else to do we need to lynch 2 mafia tonight

WITHDRAW LYNCH. after further inspection, i think i know who mafia is. LYNCH edgar

sorry hesur, i didnt look into it enough

Erm...devin got an innocent result on me...

No one was lynched. As mafia now control 50% of the votes, they have taken control of the town.

I can now reveal the roles of the final 4 people:

Spoiler:

Congrats to the mafia on their win and thanks to everyone else for playing

EZ PZ

Fucking Dev and his shit cop report.

Well played Edgar Wallace, deserved victory.

yes well done Christopher Wallace. dat wallace and gregromit

nice

He got his decision on me wrong .

Well done though.

Literaly IDed two of the mafia to jonny on the first night. Good move killing me

All fell through when you decide to kill the doc...
And dev did tell me he confirmed edgar to be town... the fuck is up with that

Your own fault for playing terribly and then not claiming that you were the doc.

[quote="Mick"]All fell through when you decide to kill the doc...
And dev did tell me he confirmed edgar to be town... the fuck is up with that[/quote]

You were the Doc? - I thought you did quite well in the beginning of the game when there was no kills on Night 2 and 3. - I assume you protected the cop, or mafia failed to send in a night action.

A Mafia Godfather will show up as not guilty on a cop report. The cop shouldn't have got the answer 'town' when asking the mod.

The game was full of WIFOM. Everyone has to question every vote if it looks suspicious/stupid with no reason and every theory that someone has. There was hardly any discussion and the two no-lynches didn't help matters. On Day 3 you pretty much found yourselves in the same position as Day 1.. if there was more discussion, you'd have probably been able to make some connections to Maddude, ask questions, look at the lynch votes from Day 1 and 2 and see who Mad and others voted. - the worst thing you could've done was start a bandwagon as scum will have just blended in with simple reasons.

To highlight the difference: A mafia game on GPRO currently has 2818 posts and is on Day 2.