Like I said, I really think we should have had a public poll on the idea Ghost suggested but I guess this is my suggestion.

1. League Format is 4v4

2. Roster sizes of 6-12

3. No draft - People pick and choose their teams

4. Still make a captain application thread. Reason I say this is because we don't want a captain to sign up his or her team then leave or become inactive

5. No being forced to 'cut the fat' after the season ends. This works for a draft but it seems pointless with the suggestion I am raising

---------------------------------------

League:

1. People can trade and switch around clubs as much as they want and sign free agents during pre season and during the first 2 gameweeks.

2. After Gameweek 2, no player can be traded from another club, although free agents can still be signed.

3. During the midpoint, a window is open where players can trade between teams again. This would last for 4 gameweeks

4. After that it closes, again free agents can still be signed and cut

I'd like to note that a player can leave the club at any point, but he cant be signed by another team until the window opens. This would stop people violating the rules. A player that just signs up without a current team though, can be picked up at any point


Other things we could include in the league:

1. A 1v1 ladder. This would be a flexible structure where players can challenge each other whenever they like

2. A 3v3 cup with the best teams entering the 3v3 CL

3. Fun cup. Teams play in teams of 1-4 playing custom maps such as Airhockey, Ice Hockey and Haxketball


Thankyou for reading

Wp Hesur, besy suggestion. Admins should pick up on this

i like it..also we should use the YeS fixture/playing system also

Totally agree with big C

hesur4presidant

#Hesur4Admin

Is it a bird
Is it a plane

NO! It's a suggestion that was actually good. WP.

Yeah, good suggestion. Should definitely be looked into, and will be for season 5.

Sounds good.

Like I said in the other thread I'd just carry with the cup until the new site is up then restart season 4 then. I'd keep the current teams as they are though, stick with these teams through the cup then have one final optional trim of teams after the cup. Once were on the new site I'd then open up the free agency so players can start getting signed for season 4. That way players training doesn't go to waste because it'll predominantly be the same team as now. We need progression or we'll end up moving backwards.

I think it was Girgensons once said we were in one of the better positions because we're English speaking, but we need to help ourselves to get up there with the big leagues.

#HES4ADMIN

Gonna put it in my signature

BIG C IN THE BLOCK

Go on Hesur speak for the rest of the Community

Nice suggestions!

This is more or less what I was thinking when I first spoke to ghost.

Best suggestion so far

#HESUR FOR ADMIN

Sidenote - I like the Haxketball idea

I certainly agree with the suggestion C! YeS is a successful league, and the suggestions you've offered, seem to be along the same lines as YeS and how it's structured. Breaking up a team with chemistry at each season end, is another negative to be honest. Hopefully admins can pick up on this as Ovo has already mentioned.

Am I the only one that likes the draft system?¿
It just needs an improvement. Making the players signing in the draft tell their real identity/past identities. And if it's found out that they lie there just ban them... As easy as that you can avoid draft cheating and keep the draft and the trades, that's what makes this league different.
Also penalyzing captains cheating in trades with inactive players and all that stuff and don't letting those trades happen...

That's just over complicating it and the leagues got to a point where it's too big to have a draft. FM won't move forward if it carries on with the draft.

I understand cutting the roster of squads at the end of the season when FM used to be small.

But allowing a maximum roster of 12 and at the end of the season telling captains to cut the squad size back to 4 is ridiculous. All the fun and good times you had with those players, inevitably you have to cut them just because of the way the league is being run.

The trimming of players is for the draft, so if there isn't a draft, there won't be trimming of players.

Scrap the Draft then

Scrap the dfart

Nah I like the draft. Remember the excitement and drama surrounding each of the drafts. Also, it gives different teams a chance of winning things, rather than a couple of teams claiming the best players and winning constantly, and the trading of draft picks makes for interesting trades and certain teams being able to benefit, and some losing out from bad deals.

I'd suggest having a minimum of 8 players per team, a maximum of 12, and keeping 6 at the end of the season, so the core of the team can remain, but it gives a chance for newer players to play at a decent level and prove themselves, which I think would be affected if there wasn't a draft, as a lot of teams would just stick with their full team.

I don't understand how it's any different to anything that's already been said?

A poll is probably needed for sure though, it'd be wise to gauge what the majority of the forum wants and try and act based on that.



League/trading rules seem good but I think I'd prefer continual trading to windows.

Joe runs a 3v3 cup for CL quali anyway, and we've tried 1v1 ladders and every single one seems to have failed before it even really got started. We need someone dedicated to actually run it properly.

I like the draft system but it's pretty obvious now that it just doesn't work anymore and we've seen it abused so much that it's basically pointless. This is probably the best suggestion for the league.